Things to consider | Read Naturally Live or Read Naturally Encore | One Minute Reader Live |
Do your students need intervention or supported practice? | Instructional intervention - Supports developing and struggling readers who read at or below an eighth-grade level.
- Improves fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension.
| Independent reading activity - Supports any student who reads at or below a fifth-grade level.
- Improves fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension during independent reading time.
|
Do you need to be able to differentiate instruction? | Direct teacher involvement Student needs teacher approval. Provides a high level of accountability. Teacher controls: - Number of read alongs.
- Number of one‐minute practice reads.
- Requirements for completing passage and setting goal.
| Student‐managed Student controls: - Number of read alongs.
- Number of one-minute practice reads.
- Criteria for successful completion of passage.
|
Do you need to use data to drive instruction? | Data shows student progress over time Extensive reports available: - Individual.
- Group (Read Naturally Live only).
Data stored indefinitely. | Data shows snapshot of student performance Limited reporting capabilities: - End of story.
- End of book (five stories).
Data stored only until a new user signs into the book. |
How great is student need? | Instructional intervention or differentiated Instruction School use: - Fits RTI needs.
- Provides intensive reading support.
- Appropriate for whole class, small groups, or individuals.
- Appropriate for Tier 1, 2, or 3 readers who read at or below an eighth-grade level.
| Structured reading practice School use: - Supports primary fluency instruction in school.
- Provides structured reading practice.
- Use as an independent reading-time activity.
- Appropriate for Tier 1 readers who read at or below a fifth-grade level.
|
Does your hardware support the product? | Read Naturally Live: - Web‐based; user can access from any computer or tablet with an internet connection that meets the minimum requirements.
Read Naturally Encore: - User reads from printed copies of the stories and listens to audio CDs.
| Web-based - User can access from any computer or tablet with an internet connection that meets the minimum requirements.
|
What are some differences between the intervention and reading activity? | Read Naturally Live (web-based on a computer, iPad, or Chromebook): - Accuracy information and unknown/difficult word data is stored.
- Results are compiled in words correct per minute (wcpm).
- One-minute, two-minute, and whole-story timings available.
- Audio provided at three speeds.
- Student can click on any word for pronunciation.
- Crossword puzzles available online (PDF format).
- Wordtastic word game available.
Encore: - 1-minute, 2-minute, and whole-story timings available.
- Vocabulary words and definitions supported by audio.
- Audio provided at three speeds.
- Crossword puzzles available online (PDF format).
| Web-based on a computer, iPad, or Chromebook - Results are compiled in words per minute (wpm), not words correct per minute (wcpm), since accuracy is not assessed.
- Only one-minute timings available.
- Audio provided at one speed.
- Student can click on individual words for pronunciation and definitions.
- Fun facts (Did You Know?) included.
|
Things to consider | Read Naturally Live or Read Naturally Encore | One Minute Reader Live |